I don’t know about you guys, but I woke up in the morning and was still on a high. What a show!
The episode is (obviously) all over the news today, and I’m sure we’ll be posting stories and reactions continuously as we see things that particularly strike us. Here are just a couple that I thought were worth pointing out.
The New Republic had a pretty thorough analysis of each guest’s appearance and concluded that the night belonged to Obama:
The Colbert Wars
Sacha Zimmerman
17.04.2008Just when I thought I was about to settle in for a Colbert Report with Hillary Clinton as the guest, Stephen Colbert hits me with an additional trifecta of political force: Representative Patrick Murphy, Senator John Edwards, and Barack Obama himself. If it was supposed to be Clinton’s night, it sure didn’t end up that way.
. . .
So over all, Clinton’s appearance is upstaged by the golden-boys twin set: one of whom has explicitly endorsed her opponent, and the other of whom has managed to say something earnest about real issues and be funny at the same time. Suddenly, Clinton’s “Call me!” walk-on is looking a touch, um, weak. Which is why it’s almost too much when Barack Obama appears on screen to chat with Colbert. And what does Obama do? He puts manufactured issues and political distractions “on notice.” With a little help from Colbert, “distractions” are now lower than dirt–you know, distractions like the Clinton camp accusing Obama of plagerizing and talking to hippies.
When it comes to the Clinton cameo versus the Obama cameo, I think that Clinton’s bit was actually funnier; but that’s the battle not the war. As we used to say in law school (cough, cough, dropped out), it’s the totality of circumstances that make the case. And, last night, in the court of Colbert, Obama was the victor.
I agree that, between the two remaining candidates for the Democtatic nomination, the show skewed pretty clearly toward Obama, but I truly felt that the night belonged to John Edwards. At least one blogger for The Los Angeles Times appears to concur:
John Edwards (finally) gets a star turn, courtesy of Stephen Colbert
Hillary Clinton (to start the show) and Barack Obama (to end it) made brief (very brief) appearances on “The Colbert Report” tonight. But it was the Democratic rival they left in the dust almost three months ago — John Edwards — who stole the show.
Edwards strolled onto Stephen Colbert’s set to punctuate the point the comic was making that in a race between a woman and a black, the key to success in their battles has hinged — and presumably will continue to depend — on which one white men support.
It’s about time this demographic ruled, Colbert smirked. And Edwards quipped that no white male voter is being “more vigorously courted than this one.”
He began his shtick by reiterating that he remains undecided — and provided some elaboration as to why. On the one hand, he said, he doesn’t want to be seen as “anti-hope.” With fine timing, he added: “On the other hand, I don’t want James Carville to bite me.”
He then detailed some expected — and unexpected — ways that Clinton or Obama might win him over.
. . .
As someone who felt that John Edwards was always given the short shrift in media coverage during the early days of the campaign and who was disappointed when he ended his candidacy, it was slightly bittersweet to see him back on the (sort of) political stage last night. But man, he nailed it, and I give him all kinds of credit for that.
I repeat: what a show!
WOOO!!! I must say that I was MOST excited to see John Edwards — I hadn’t read any of the spoiler reports, so I was TRULY SURPRISED!
And, of course, I too thought that he “stole the show.”
The “ED-Word” was HILARIOUS!
That should probably be a reoccuring segment.
Shout Out (Hey!):
0
“As someone who felt that John Edwards was always given the short shrift in media coverage during the early days of the campaign and who was disappointed when he ended his candidacy, it was slightly bittersweet to see him back on the (sort of) political stage last night.”
That is EXACTLY how I felt.
Shout Out (Hey!):
0
I always like Edwards too, and was highly disappointed when he left the race. But last night’s show bumped him back up so much in my book, that he’s probably higher than he was to begin with.
They should let him back into the race. Maybe there’s some loophole? lol.
Shout Out (Hey!):
0
Maybe if Obama had been there in person it would have been different, but Edwards totally owned it last night!! He definitely got the most applause out of anyone; the audience basically FREAKED when he walked onto the stage, with a standing ovation. And he did so well that we were still clapping once he left the stage, to the point where they brought him back out for another bow. And more clapping! So much clapping! My poor wrists.
Shout Out (Hey!):
0
Yeah, I was a little upset that all the guests except Hillary got to say something substantial.
But damn, I wish Edwards were still in the race.
Shout Out (Hey!):
0
@gaia faye
i’m so jealous! that was an explosive show to have gone to. i’m gonna hold judgment on whether or not that was the greatest episode, but i’m pretty sure that was one of the biggest (next to stephen’s presidential announcement).
Shout Out (Hey!):
0
AHH! LOVED this episode – loved it loved it loved it. Epic. As someone mentioned in a previous thread, it’s sure to be mentioned in future Colbert Report documentaries. :) Thirty years from now I can sit in my rocker and knit and say in an old-lady voice, “I saw that show on television the day after it was aired…”
Shout Out (Hey!):
0
Can he get another Peabody for this one?
Shout Out (Hey!):
0
I loved the last PA show with all the Candidates. I thought Edwards was especially funny. I liked the ‘Distractions’ on notice as well.
Following the show, the ColBear Bump for Obama Bear can definitely be seen on the Vermont Teddy Bear Presidential Bear polling.
Trailing Obama Bear as of the 18th, we have Hillary Bear, then McCain Bear.
Obama Bear 36.97%
Clinton Bear 24.46%
McCain Bear 20.04%
Mom Bear 18.53%
Knowing how much Colbear loves bear’s… Perhaps we’ll see the Stephen ColBEAR Bear at some point???
Shout Out (Hey!):
0
If this past week doesn’t have “Emmy” written all over it, I don’t know what does!
Shout Out (Hey!):
0
definitely emmy worthy!
Shout Out (Hey!):
0